SBIR-STTR Award

Reliable model building for cryo-EM
Award last edited on: 2/17/2024

Sponsored Program
SBIR
Awarding Agency
NIH : NIGMS
Total Award Amount
$1,943,582
Award Phase
2
Solicitation Topic Code
859
Principal Investigator
Yirui Guo

Company Information

Ligo Analytics Inc

2207 Chunk Court
Dallas, TX 75206
   (214) 336-9167
   contactligoanalytics@gmail.com
   www.kitware.com
Location: Single
Congr. District: 32
County: Dallas

Phase I

Contract Number: 1R43GM137671-01A1
Start Date: 8/1/2020    Completed: 7/31/2021
Phase I year
2020
Phase I Amount
$223,916
Reliability of structural models is important for mechanistic studies of cellular processes and for rational design of drugs and treatment. Cryo-EM single particle reconstruction (Cryo-EM SPR) is an expanding technique that can generate atomic models for structural biology and has the advantage that it does not require samples to be crystallized. Instead, atomic models are built based on maps obtained by averaging hundreds of thousands of weak images, with each image containing snapshots of individual macromolecules suspended in a thin layer of ice. Due to the intrinsic difficulties with averaging noisy images, cryo-EM maps frequently have limited resolution and may represent averages of multiple structural states. Building and rebuilding structural models reliably in such maps remains a challenge and the process is additionally complicated by the lack of established criteria for validating the quality of models built at low resolution. When groups of a few atoms are individually recognizable in maps, established methods easily create reliable models. However, it is problematic when only larger groups of atoms are individually recognizable, and this is referred to as low resolution. It has been observed that for resolutions as low as 5 Å, reliable models can be built (with effort) if the maps are highly precise. This observation is an important factor for our plan to develop and implement methods for automatic, comprehensive and accurate building of atomic models for such low resolution. To achieve this goal, in Aim 1 we will improve the low resolution quality of cryo-EM maps by computing maps so that they are corrected for physical effects currently not properly considered in map creation. In Aim 2, we will develop and implement an integrative procedure for automatic model building at low resolution. It will combine a fast 6D search using a library of continuous and discontinuous fragments obtained through the data mining of known structures. The hypotheses obtained from the 6D search will be analyze for forming self- consistent groups in a multi-stage process. This will be followed by GPU-accelerated molecular dynamics computations restrained by experimental data. The output of dynamics will undergo an additional layer of data mining to identify and trigger corrections of problematic starting assumptions and to create a concise description of information present in a multitude of calculated structural states. The final step will involve an assessment of possible unresolved ambiguities by the experimenter, who may have additional relevant knowledge guiding the selection of a specific structural hypothesis. Our SBIR phase I proposal will result in two software modules that will be incorporated into a commercial solution for data processing, analysis, and validation in cryo-EM.

Public Health Relevance Statement:
Project Narrative Cryo-EM single particle reconstruction (Cryo-EM SPR) can generate accurate models of macromolecules that help us understand cellular processes in health and disease at the molecular level. However, building accurate structural models based on cryo-EM data is still challenging due to insufficient detail in the maps frequently obtained from cryo-EM SPR experiments. We will develop methods to more efficiently use the low resolution parts of cryo-EM maps and combine these methods with new approaches for building high quality structural models, so that cryo-EM can enlarge the project space for which it is a prime technique.

Project Terms:
Affect; Algorithms; Back; Dorsum; Cell physiology; Cell Function; Cell Process; Cellular Function; Cellular Physiology; Cellular Process; Subcellular Process; Classification; Systematics; Crystallization; Disease; Disorder; Drug Design; Pharmacotherapy; Drug Therapy; drug treatment; Elements; Feedback; Goals; Health; Ice; Industry; Information Distribution; Libraries; Maps; Methods; Structural Models; Molecular Conformation; Molecular Configuration; Molecular Stereochemistry; conformation; conformational state; Molecular Structure; Macromolecular Structure; Motion; Computer software; Software; Technology; Testing; Thinness; Leanness; Time; United States Food and Drug Administration; Food and Drug Administration; USFDA; Weight; base; macromolecule; improved; Procedures; Phase; Biological; Chemicals; Evaluation; Individual; Epitope Mapping; Collaborations; Letters; Deposit; Deposition; Knowledge; Side; Techniques; 3-D; 3D; three dimensional; 3-Dimensional; Molecular Dynamics Simulation; molecular dynamics; parallel processing; particle; structural biology; Cryo-electron Microscopy; Electron Cryomicroscopy; cryo-EM; cryoEM; Cryoelectron Microscopy; a-helix; alpha helix; Structure; Modeling; Sampling; drug discovery; data processing; computerized data processing; datamining; data mining; Address; Academia; Data; Homology Modeling; Resolution; Ligand Binding; SBIR; Small Business Innovation Research; Small Business Innovation Research Grant; Validation; Molecular; Process; imaging; Image; Output; reconstruction; markov model; new approaches; novel approaches; novel strategy; novel strategies; radiation damage; Radiation induced damage; new drug treatments; new drugs; new therapeutics; new therapy; next generation therapeutics; novel drug treatments; novel drugs; novel therapy; novel therapeutics; model building; Formulation; experiment; experimental research; experimental study; structured data

Phase II

Contract Number: 2R44GM137671-02
Start Date: 8/1/2020    Completed: 4/30/2024
Phase II year
2022
(last award dollars: 2023)
Phase II Amount
$1,719,666

Atomic models generated by experimental structural biology are used to understand cellular processes at the molecular level, and also for rational design of drugs and treatments. Cryogenic electron microscopy single particle reconstruction (cryo-EM SPR) generates such atomic models based on interpretation of maps of Coulomb potential that are obtained by averaging many thousands of weak images, with each image containing projection snapshots of individual macromolecules suspended in a thin layer of ice. Consequently, cryo-EM maps represent averages of structural states and frequently have limited and uneven quality resulting from both flexibility of particles used in cryo-EM SPR as well as their non-random distributions in ice called preferred orientation. Building and rebuilding structural models in maps that are low quality due to lack of detail (resolution) or having sampling and reconstruction problems is a challenge. In this proposal, we will address these challenges by developing and implementing methods for automatic and comprehensive model building and validation with carefully designed feedback loops to experimental data analysis. The initial and intermediate models generated by our model building methods will aid cryo-EM SPR projects by stabilizing convergence of computations at all steps of reconstruction, but without introducing bias, with bias removal and quantification being addressed explicitly. Aim 1 will focus on methods that will use ab initio predicted models or experimental models to improve cryo-EM SPR so that they can be used without introducing bias. In Aim 2, a new weighting of information for refinement and validation of the structural models will be developed and implemented to account for uneven quality of information in cryo-EM SPR. Aim 3 will focus on developing and implementing methods for directly coupling 2D classification to model building. Finally, Aim 4 will target analysis and modeling of internal motions to guide the structural interpretation and to improve the resolution of reconstructions. The results will be incorporated into the commercially distributed suite cryoEMMA. The competitive advantage of these approaches arises from their ability to provide highly informative 3D reconstructions in the presence of severe preferred orientation and for single particle signal-to-noise lower than in the current approaches.

Public Health Relevance Statement:
Project Narrative Cryogenic electron microscopy single particle reconstruction (cryo-EM SPR) can provide detailed models of macromolecules that provide insight into mechanisms of cellular processes in health and disease and guide discovery of treatments. However, building accurate structural models into maps generated by cryo-EM SPR is a challenge, in particular when the resolution of these maps is low or when particles used in the cryo-EM SPR process are not oriented randomly. We will develop and implement methods combining new approaches for building high quality structural models for maps of limited detail and quality with novel procedures improving interpretability of cryo-EM SPR in the presence non-randomly oriented particles so that cryo-EM SPR can be used even for difficult cases.

Project Terms:
Alpha Particles; Alpha Particle Radiation; Alpha Radiation; a Particles; Architecture; Engineering / Architecture; Cell physiology; Cell Function; Cell Process; Cellular Function; Cellular Physiology; Cellular Process; Subcellular Process; Classification; Systematics; Data Analyses; Data Analysis; data interpretation; Disease; Disorder; Pharmacotherapy; Drug Therapy; drug treatment; Feedback; Freedom; Liberty; Health; Ice; Maps; Methods; Electron Microscopy; Structural Models; Motion; Noise; Proteins; Running; Cell Communication and Signaling; Cell Signaling; Intracellular Communication and Signaling; Signal Transduction Systems; Signaling; biological signal transduction; Signal Transduction; Software; Computer software; Leanness; Thinness; Translations; Weight; Work; Articular Range of Motion; Joint Range of Motion; range of motion; Experimental Models; Data Set; Dataset; base; macromolecule; improved; Procedures; Phase; insight; Individual; restraint; Complex; 3-D; 3D; three dimensional; 3-Dimensional; vibration; particle; structural biology; Cryo-electron Microscopy; Electron Cryomicroscopy; cryo-EM; cryoEM; Cryoelectron Microscopy; cryogenics; Molecular Modeling Nucleic Acid Biochemistry; Molecular Modeling Protein/Amino Acid Biochemistry; Molecular Models; molecular modeling; Structure; novel; Abscission; Extirpation; Removal; Surgical Removal; resection; Excision; Modeling; Sampling; Address; Resolution; Small Business Innovation Research Grant; SBIR; Small Business Innovation Research; Validation; Molecular; Process; Grouping; groupings; Development; developmental; Image; imaging; reconstruction; predictive modeling; computer based prediction; prediction model; design; designing; novel strategies; new approaches; novel approaches; novel strategy; Coupling; flexibility; flexible; model building; guided inquiry; guided discovery; rational design