SBIR-STTR Award

Low-Cost Resin for Large Format Additive Manufacturing
Award last edited on: 7/21/2023

Sponsored Program
SBIR
Awarding Agency
DOD : AF
Total Award Amount
$797,743
Award Phase
2
Solicitation Topic Code
AF203-CSO1
Principal Investigator
Austin Schmidt

Company Information

Additive Engineering Solutions LLC

980 Evans Avenue
Akron, OH 44305
   (419) 571-2325
   N/A
   www.additiveeng.com
Location: Single
Congr. District: 13
County: Summit

Phase I

Contract Number: FA8649-21-P-0437
Start Date: 2/5/2021    Completed: 5/3/2021
Phase I year
2021
Phase I Amount
$49,778
Industry use of Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) for tooling and components made via Large Format Additive Manufacturing has been growing due to the lead time improvements, cost savings, and design flexibility enabled by the technology. However, the cost of the most commonly used material (carbon- fiber filled ABS) limits the range of applications for which these advantages can be economically realized. This project will prove the efficacy of ultra-low cost blends of ABS for use in large format tooling and components. Representative parts will be made using various ultra-low cost blends of ABS. Our target for resin cost reduction over the industry standard material is 80%; we are hoping to drive costs per pound from $5.50/lb to $1.10/lb. To validate our new blends of material, the warpage and shrinkage of test parts resulting from those blends will be measured to and compared to the baseline carbon fiber filled material. Success on this project will enable meaningful reductions in cost and lead times in a variety of defense and commercial applications, including but not limited to flight simulators, composite tooling, and concrete formworks. Reduction in the cost of LFAM-ABS provides opportunities to deliver faster lead times, significant cost savings, and greater design flexibility in a broader range of applications. Applications relevant to the Air Force include but are not limited to: Tooling for Low Temperature (<150F) Large Format Composite Parts, Examples include drill, trim and assembly tools for aerospace structures and tooling repair. Per Craig Neslin of the Air Force Additive Manufacturing Directorate: “The use of rapidly produced, low cost composite tooling is an enabling technology to meet future anticipated system cost and producibility requirements.” Modular Frames for Flight Simulators LFAM ABS can be helpful in realizing the goals of the SCARS initiative, the focus of which is on a modular open systems approach, as well as a set of common standards for Air Force simulators, according to a Defense Department announcement. For example, in an active project with a current client, AES has demonstrated the ability to design a flight simulator frame using LFAM ABS that results in an exponential decrease in part count reducing what was previously 100s of part down to 3. This reduction in part count has reduced cost, simplified the supply chain and reduced the lead time required for the customer to procure the units. Further driving down the cost of ABS as this proposal intends to do will directly translate into cheaper simulator frames for future simulator programs and designs.

Phase II

Contract Number: FA8649-21-P-1449
Start Date: 8/9/2021    Completed: 10/10/2022
Phase II year
2021
Phase II Amount
$747,965
Industry acceptance of tooling and components made from Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS) using Large Format Additive Manufacturing (LFAM) has been growing due to the lead time improvements, cost savings, design flexibility enabled for large format AM parts (Parts over 3’ in any or all directions), and the advancement of production and material technologies that enable production-quality parts. However, advantages afforded by this technology are not evenly distributed over all geometries needed in the marketplace. Due to high resin material costs, and elevated machine operating cost, some tools and parts produced by LFAM-ABS are equal to, or more expensive than their traditionally manufactured counterparts. Convention in the industry is that unfilled ABS and glass filled ABS resins are not dimensionally stable enough to be useful in an LFAM process and that carbon-fiber filled ABS is the best viable solution. Early work completed by Oak Ridge National Laboratory showed that part warp and distortion were significantly reduced with the inclusion of the carbon fiber. However, the inclusion of carbon fiber in the resin can increase the cost by a factor of 5. In Phase I of our SBIR, we have already proven printability of our low-cost blended resin, which is approximately 30% the cost of the industry standard carbon filled ABS. The main goal of this SBIR Phase II effort is to fully characterize and make ready for commercial use our blended ABS resin. Completing this research and demonstrating its effectiveness by producing demonstration tooling for our AF Customer will validate the blended resin as a suitable material for LFAM. This will create a “Platform Effect” in which the material can serve as the resin of choice for numerous Defense and Non-Defense applications.